24 Wishes

Created/Updated 2003-01-12



Animephile Rating: D

Perhaps I'm being too harsh with a 'D' rating, but it's a close one anyway. I'm sorry. Really I am. Considering there are only 11 tracks (for Y3,045 thank you very much), so many of them are just re-used songs from Chobits anime. Not only that, these new versions with different lyrics and/or different mixing tricks are worse than the original ones from various Chobits CDs. And all the new songs are boring and lifeless both musically and technically.

For your information, her debut CDs (Club Rie Rie #1, #2, and Garnet) are being re-released. I'd advise people to get Garnet instead of this CD if you're interested in her vocals. Heck, I like some of the the incomplete songs in Club Rie Rie #1 better than any of the songs on this CD!

I keep getting this feeling that somewhere after her role as Saki, she's been losing the special charm that made Tanaka Rie so interesting before. shiku shiku =(



Back to Seiyuu-Tanaka Rie Index Page
Back to Animephile Homepage